Page 1
THE DISCLOSURE CMC · A GUIDE FOR UK LAWYERS
Technical Preparation for a Disclosure
Case Management Conference
Walking In With the Answers
COMPUTER FORENSICS LAB
DISCOVERY. UK
§ ABOUT THE AUTHOR
PREPARED BY COMPUTER FORENSICS LAB E-DISCOVERY TEAM
FULL CHAIN-OF-CUSTODY DOCUMENTATION
§ CONTENTS
In this guide
01 Executive summary
02 The problem in plain English: twenty minutes that design a year
03 The legal frame: what the hearing is, and what it expects
04 Briefing area 1 · Systems and sources
05 Briefing area 2 · Volumes
06 Briefing area 3 · Preservation and collection progress
07 Briefing area 4 · Search methodology
08 Briefing area 5 · Technology-assisted review
09 Briefing area 6 · Production formats
10 Briefing area 7 · Unresolved technical issues
11 The pack, the people and the timeline
12 Advocacy: presenting technical material to the court
13 Worked example · Common mistakes and limitations
14 Questions to ask · Suggested wording
15 The master checklist · Red flags · When to involve a digital forensic expert
16 Frequently asked questions
17 Glossary · References · Disclaimer · How a specialist laboratory can assist
§ 01 · ORIENTATION
Executive summary
THE HEADLINE POINT: THEPREPAREDPARTYWRITESTHEORDER
§ 02 · FIRST PRINCIPLES
The problem in plain English: twenty minutes that design a year
§ 03 · THELAW
The legal frame: what the hearing is, and what it expects
Page 2
§ 04 · BRIEFINGAREA1
Systems and sources
§ 05 · BRIEFINGAREA2
Volumes
§ 06 · BRIEFINGAREA3
Preservation and collection progress
§ 07 · BRIEFINGAREA4
Search methodology
§ 08 · BRIEFINGAREA5
Technology-assisted review
§ 09 · BRIEFINGAREA6
Production formats
Page 3
§ 10 · BRIEFINGAREA7
Unresolved technical issues
§ 11 · LOGISTICS
The pack, the people and the timeline
The pack
The people
The timeline
WHEN DONE
2 weeks out DRD substantially agreed except the true disputes; disputed-issues schedule drafted and
1 week out Filing per the order or PD deadlines; one-page summary finalised; fallback positions
§ 12 · THEHEARING
Advocacy: presenting technical material to the court
§ 13 · IN THE WILD, ANDWHEREITGOESWRONG
Worked example · Common mistakes and limitations
WORKED EXAMPLE · THECCMCTHATTOOKELEVENMINUTES
Common mistakes
Technical limitations
§ 14 · INTERROGATORIES & DRAFTING AIDS
Questions to ask · Suggested wording
Ask your client (pre-hearing)
Ask your opponent (pre-hearing)
Ask your e Discovery / forensic provider
SUGGESTED WORDING · SKELETONARGUMENT PA R AG RAPHINTRODUCINGTHE
TECHNICALPOSITION
§ 15 · QUICK CONTROL
The master checklist · Red flags · When to involve a digital
forensic expert
The CMC technical preparation checklist
Red flags
When to involve a digital forensic expert
Page 4
§ 16 · COMMON QUESTIONS
Frequently asked questions
Should our e Discovery provider or examiner actually attend the hearing? What if we genuinely do not have final volumes by the CMC? The other side keeps adding demands in the final week. How do we handle the ambush? What is a Disclosure Guidance Hearing, and when do we ask for one? How does this differ outside the Business and Property Courts, or in criminal proceedings?
§ 17 · REFERENCE
Glossary
DGH
DMD
EDQ
Sources and authoritative references
DISCLAIMER
§ HOW A SPECIALIST LABORATORY CAN ASSIST
Working with Computer Forensics Lab
Speak to a forensic examiner, not a salesperson. INSTRUCTTHELAB
NEWENQUIRIESEMAILE - DISCOVERY